Trigger Warning: This post revisits themes of physical punishment and trauma from United Christian Boys Hostel, now exploring the immediate aftermath for the enforcer. Reader discretion advised. Based on my lived experience, written as the memory blurs yet persists.
The Reckoning I Witnessed:
What Happened to the Study Incharge?
When I shared the searing memory of those 80-90 hand strikes in the crowded sleeping room of United Christian Boys Hostel, I left a question lingering—one I know many of you have pondered. What became of the study incharge, that 6th or 7th grader who swung a wooden stick with such force over my zero on an English test? Did he walk away unscathed, leaving my pain as a distant echo? Or did the universe, in its unyielding way, demand a reckoning?
As I write this tonight, October 16, 2025, at 08:56 PM IST, the answer floods back—not years later, as a distant discovery, but in the same year, unfolding before my eyes. The memory is blurring now, edges softening with time, yet the moment remains etched: his fall from grace happened right there in the hostel, a silent drama I witnessed amid the cots and double-deckers. He failed his academic year, the weight of those rigid expectations crushing him as they once crushed me. And then, he was expelled—thrown out of the hostel in shame, his authority stripped away. I never saw him again.
A Live Reversal: Justice or Shared Fall?
That sight—watching him stumble under the same system that handed him a stick to strike me—felt like a live reversal of roles. Where I stood at the center of the room, palms throbbing under his gaze and the eyes of 12-14 peers, he became the one proclaimed a failure, his exit a public unraveling. For those of you who love a happy ending, this might seem like poetic justice served hot, a bully undone by his own hand. And yes, in that moment, a part of me felt a raw, fleeting relief—a whisper of “finally” amid the blur of my own pain.
But the truth was messier. He wasn’t a monster; he was a boy, like me, caught in the same “mini-military camp” trap. The system that demanded my perfection with a cane demanded his with grades, and when he fell short, it discarded him without mercy. I saw it happen—his head bowed, his belongings packed, the whispers of other boys filling the space where his authority once stood. It wasn’t just his punishment; it was the system’s failure laid bare, punishing us both in different ways. The universe didn’t single him out—it exposed the flaw we both endured.
The Blurring Memory and Its Weight
That same-year reckoning has shaped how this memory lingers. The strikes, the pain radiating up my arms, the silence of my roommates—all blur at the edges now, softened by decades. But watching him leave, his shame mirroring my own, remains sharp, a dual image of resilience and ruin. It fueled the grit I carry today, the same grit that later drove me and other seniors to abolish the study incharge system. His exit wasn’t my victory; it was a warning sign we heeded, pushing for change where brutality once reigned.
Does this mean he “paid off his sins,” as some might hope? Perhaps, if you see justice as a direct exchange. But to me, it’s less about his penance and more about the lesson: no one wins when a system values force over support. His failure, witnessed in real-time, wasn’t a happy ending—it was a mirror to my own survival, a call to break the cycle.
The Power of Sharing, Refocused
Sharing my vulnerability in the first part felt like stepping back into that room, the air thick with tension. Adding this chapter—knowing his fate unfolded before me—deepens that act. It’s not just my story now; it’s ours, a shared cautionary tale from that blurring memory. If you’ve wondered about him, it’s because you’ve felt the human stakes, the need for resolution. That’s why I write: to connect those hostel realities to a world learning to choose empathy over canes.
Tonight, as the clock ticks past 08:56 PM, I’m struck by how this live witnessing shaped me. His fall didn’t heal my hands or erase the trauma, but it lit a spark—to survive, to reform, to share. This isn’t about reveling in his shame; it’s about recognizing how we both paid a price, and how I chose to turn mine into something better.
Toward a Kinder Future
For those craving a happy ending, this might not fit the mold. There’s no redemption arc for him—at least, not one I saw as he left the hostel gates. But there’s hope in the changes we fought for: the end of the study incharge system, the growing global push against corporal punishment (echoed by UN and child rights advocates). My story, and his sudden exit, underscores that empathy—through tutoring, support, and understanding—builds strength without breaking spirits.
Have you witnessed a system turn on its enforcers, or found resilience where rigidity once ruled? Share your thoughts below—I’d love to hear how these blurring memories shape your present, as they continue to shape mine. Let’s keep this dialogue alive, building a future where no child faces a stick or a shameful exit.
Comments
Post a Comment